• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream – Best Variety and Friendly Service in Drums, PA

Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream, nestled in Drums, PA, offers a delightful escape for ice cream lovers. With an extensive menu featuring hard dip, soft serve, sundaes, flurries, and slushies, there’s something for every taste. Highlights include rich salted caramel and classic banana splits, all at reasonable prices. The friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere enhance the experience, especially on the new patio with shaded picnic tables. While some flavors may vary, the large portions and diverse selections make Sleepy Hollow a standout destination. It’s a perfect spot to indulge in quality ice cream surrounded by warm community vibes.

Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream at a glance

  • Address 368 W Butler Dr, Drums, PA 18222, United States
  • Phone +1 570-861-0992
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream: Reviews & Ratings

Maxie Max
5

Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream had such a large selection that it was a difficult to decide what I should get. I got a regular size hard ice cream in a bowl, salted caramel. The regular size was so big I had to take 1/2 of it home. You will find a new patio with picnic tables that have umbrellas to sheild you from the hot sun while you sit and enjoy your ice cream.

Stephanie Probert
5

Absolutely the Best Ice Cream in the Drums and surrounding areas. So much to choose from. Owners and staff are the best, super friendly and very helpful!

Chris Altieri
4

Ice cream shop is located in a rural area outside Drums PA. There was lots of parking. Ice cream shop is next to a good pizzeria. There is outside covered seating. Prices are fair. Lots of varieties to choose from. I'm extremely picky about my ice cream so it may seem like I'm picking. I got an Oreo flurry which was one size typical portion and taste was ok. I also ordered a cherry slushy which I did not like at all. A little disappointed.

Christine G
5

So many options!! Soft serve, hard dip, Penn State Creamery ice cream, sundaes, slushies, flurries, and more! Prices are reasonable. Indoor seating and outdoor window service. Great employees too.

mounika m
5

The ice cream is soo good. I tried the banana split which is one of my favorites now

Suzanne Parks
5

specialty flavors they have some ice cream from the Penn State creamery and they have a lactose free version called dole whip

Dale bellfield
5

Best ice cream place in the area. Never had anything bad there. Friendly staff and reasonable prices

Leanne Montinaro
5

The girls working were so sweet and super quick with my order. My sundae looked and tasted great. Definitely less expensive than other local ice cream places. And the portions are a good size in my opinion. I will drive the extra 10 minutes from now on to go to here.

Location

  • Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream
    Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream
    368 W Butler Dr, Drums, PA 18222, United States Hotline: +1 570-861-0992

Nestled in the heart of Drums, PA, Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream stands out as a charming destination for ice cream lovers craving quality and variety. This local gem, located at 368 W Butler Dr, offers an inviting atmosphere complemented by a spacious patio with picnic tables shaded by umbrellas, perfect for savoring a cool treat on a warm day.

The menu at Sleepy Hollow is impressively diverse, featuring classic favorites and creative twists alike. Standouts include the Kit Kat Sundae, which layers crunchy chocolate and creamy ice cream in perfect harmony, and the timeless Banana Split, beloved by many regulars. The Sugar Cookie Sundae offers a delightful balance of sweet and soft textures, while the Salty Caramel and Chocolate blend delivers a rich, indulgent experience that lingers pleasantly on the palate.

Seasonal specialties like the Pumpkin Spice flavor bring a cozy, festive touch, especially appreciated as the air cools. For those who enjoy a playful edge, the Halloween Sprinkles add both visual fun and a crisp crunch. Beverage options such as the Rootbeer Milkshake and refreshing Parfait provide alternatives that cater to different tastes and cravings.

Customer impressions often highlight the generous portion sizes—like the large regular salted caramel bowl praised by Maxie Max, which was satisfying enough to require saving half for later. The staff’s friendly and attentive service creates a welcoming environment, as noted by Stephanie Probert, reinforcing the shop's community-centered vibe.

While most experiences are positive, it’s worth noting some mixed feedback, such as Chris Altieri’s comment on the cherry slushy, reminding visitors to explore and find their personal favorite among the wide variety available.

Overall, Sleepy Hollow Ice Cream excels by blending quality, variety, and a warm, inviting ambiance. Whether you favor soft serve, hard dip, or inventive sundaes, this ice cream shop offers an indulgent escape for anyone seeking a sweet retreat in the Pennsylvania countryside.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards